If a team (Brelvis can get a probationary civi pass) gets an order for Cadets to disengage and scatter, and 3/4ths of the team do not follow orders, the team fails in following orders. Kaycee and Fatima are part of that team. Achieving the objective of calling in support, and hold out long enough to disrupt opposition activity until overwhelming hostile reinforcements arrived, does not mean the team got it right, and all immediate objectives have been safely accomplished.
What about Kaycee and Fatima? They both followed the protocol correctly.
If a team (Brelvis can get a probationary civi pass) gets an order for Cadets to disengage and scatter, and 3/4ths of the team do not follow orders, the team fails in following orders. Kaycee and Fatima are part of that team. Achieving the objective of calling in support, and hold out long enough to disrupt opposition activity until overwhelming hostile reinforcements arrived, does not mean the team got it right, and all immediate objectives have been safely accomplished.